To analyze local government budgets from a gender perspective, we can look at two examples, focusing on how gender budgeting principles are applied at the local level and the impact on women’s empowerment and gender equality.
Get the full solved assignment PDF of MGSE-002 of 2024-25 session now by clicking on above button.
For this analysis, I will refer to examples from Unit 14, which focuses on gender-sensitive budgeting and planning.
1. Example 1: Municipal Budget for Women’s Empowerment (Mumbai)
Budget Focus: Women’s Health and Safety
- Gender-Sensitive Allocation: In the municipal budget of Mumbai, gender-sensitive allocations are often made for women’s health, education, and safety. A significant part of the budget is allocated to initiatives like the Mumbai Mahila Arogya Yojana, which provides free health care for women in low-income areas. A portion of this is specifically earmarked for maternal health, addressing the unique health challenges women face.
- Analysis: From a gender perspective, the allocation focuses not just on general health services but targets maternal health, addressing the higher maternal mortality rates and health risks faced by women. This is an example of integrating gender-responsive budgeting where the government explicitly addresses women’s health needs, ensuring that services like prenatal and postnatal care, family planning, and reproductive health services are prioritized in the budget.
Gender-Sensitive Program:
- Mumbai Mahila Arogya Yojana (MMAY): Targets low-income women and children, focusing on reproductive health and nutritional support, thus ensuring women’s health needs are met.
- Impact: The allocation for maternal and child health improves the well-being of women, reduces maternal mortality, and addresses gender disparities in health care access. It ensures that women’s health challenges are not sidelined in general public health initiatives.
2. Example 2: Panchayat Budget for Rural Women (Kerala)
Budget Focus: Economic Empowerment and Livelihoods
- Gender-Sensitive Allocation: Kerala’s panchayat budget often includes specific provisions for the economic empowerment of rural women. In this context, the budget includes funds for the Kudumbashree Program, which is one of the largest women’s self-help programs in India.
- Analysis: Kudumbashree provides financial resources, skills training, and support to women’s collectives, encouraging them to start small businesses, manage micro-enterprises, and participate in the local economy. The Kerala government’s gender-responsive budget ensures that a dedicated portion is allocated to women’s livelihood programs that help them become financially independent.
Gender-Sensitive Program:
- Kudumbashree Program: Focuses on empowering women by improving their access to microcredit, training, and entrepreneurship. The budget for this program allows women to gain financial independence and participate in decision-making processes at the local level.
- Impact: The focus on women’s livelihoods through micro-enterprises boosts women’s economic security, reduces dependency on male members of the family, and increases women’s participation in the local economy. It also addresses social barriers that limit women’s access to economic opportunities.
Gender Budgeting Analysis Framework (from Unit 14):
- Resource Allocation: Both Mumbai and Kerala’s local budgets allocate specific resources to women-focused programs like health care, economic empowerment, and safety. These initiatives represent a departure from traditional, gender-neutral budgeting, focusing instead on meeting women’s specific needs.
- Gender Disaggregation: The gender-disaggregated data helps ensure that women-specific schemes receive adequate funding. The use of gender indicators to track the success of the programs ensures accountability and transparency in the allocation of resources.
- Intersectional Considerations: In Kerala, special attention is given to rural women, a marginalized group, in the Kudumbashree Program. This highlights the importance of an intersectional approach in gender budgeting, where rural, low-income women are given specific resources to overcome economic disadvantages.
- Outcome-Oriented: Both budgets emphasize measurable outcomes, such as improved maternal health outcomes in Mumbai and increased women’s economic participation in Kerala, thus making gender equality a goal that is tracked and evaluated within the budget process.
Conclusion
Both the Mumbai and Kerala local government budgets exemplify how gender-responsive budgeting can effectively address women’s needs and promote gender equality. By explicitly allocating resources for women’s health, safety, and economic empowerment, these local governments ensure that women’s concerns are integrated into the broader development agenda. These examples also reflect the use of gender-disaggregated data, intersectional approaches, and the focus on outcome-based budgeting, which aligns with the principles taught in Unit 14 of the course on gender-sensitive planning and budgeting.